November 2008
In This Issue
Fiction as Life PreparationTeaching Popular MaterialsReading Group TherapyNational SceneBooks and Covers in Vanity FairReaders RespondWrite!Fiction as Life Preparation
Life isn't fiction, is it? No, but sometimes it's like fiction. And sometimes fiction helps us to lead our lives. Some research shows that fiction is a way to prepare for reality, and certainly a way to engage in a social, empathic (and probably interesting) life.
Read on.Teaching Popular MaterialsIf you were asked to teach a course for readers' advisors, introducing students to the vast array of popular materials out there, what would you select? Or, more immediately, what would you tell me to select?
Read on ...Reading Group TherapyIn a recent informal talk at the Cameron Village Library in Raleigh, NC, on "Reading Group Therapy," I offered several suggestions for making changes in reading group procedures and routines. Personalities, energies and ideas in these groups can become stale or problematic over time, in my experience. Here are a few suggestions from my talk.Change at the Start In order to assure everyone of having a chance to speak up at the start of the group, I like to move around the reading circle, inviting each participant to answer these three questions, or variations on them, for one minute each - always having the option to say "No thanks, I'll pass for now."
What experiences and expectations have I brought to this book?
How did the reading match those experiences and expectations?
What do I want most to discuss about the book in the group?When everyone has a chance to express a response, the whole group gets a sense of who has deep feelings or specific perspectives on the reading. Everyone has had a chance to be heard. Dominant personalities are more likely to respect the opinions of others. By the time four or five people have spoken, the conversation has begun with a vocabulary that lasts for the entire discussion. Provide a "Reading Group Bookmark"Using similar questions, libraries might supply printed bookmarks at the circulation desk in order to suggest ways to focus reading experiences and move them toward talk. If we encounter a good question every time we find our place in a book, I think it tends to settle into our minds and keep working as we read. Eventually, our reading-inspired feelings may find their way toward our conversations (in a group or out) with another person. Here are the questions I would put on my bookmarks:
What part of my own experience is touched or changed by this book?
What questions do I feel the need to ask or answer as a result of reading this?
What part of this reading experience do I want most to speak about? Putting these questions on card stock is cheap and easy (in landscape mode, an 8.5" x 11" page can hold three bookmarks, roughly 3.5" x 8.5"). I am a note-taker when I read seriously, and my card bookmarks help me to recover lost thoughts when I look back. Would a simple device like this help readers to find their words when the reading group gathers to talk?Establish the Vocabulary Even simpler, give everyone an index card and ask them to write three words to describe the book (nouns, adjectives, characteristics, events, places in the book). Collect and shuffle the cards, then redistribute them. Do it again. And again. Then start talking about some of the words and how they fit the reading as experienced by others.
National SceneThe
National Book Award Finalists have been announced, and you can see them at
http://www.nationalbook.org/nba2008.html, a fine web site for librarians, with useful graphics and links. Seeing small presses listed - Graywolf, Coffee House, Turtle Point - and being reminded that great, fresh American poetry is still being written is gratifying news. (I have read only one of these books so far, The Suicide Index: Putting My Father's Death in Order by Joan Wickersham (Harcourt), and it was a fine, extraordinary experience.) Now I am after several others on this list. The winners will be announced during the week of November 17.There are two other "national" items on my desk, and both are new to me. Take a look at the
National Best Books 2008 Awards from USA Books, self-described as "the premiere online magazine and review web site for mainstream and independent publishing houses." Evidently this is the fifth year for this PR and marketing-based list. I don't quite know what to make of it, but it seems to be an unusual mix of winners in 140 categories. I seem also to have missed
National Reading Group Month, sponsored by the Women's National Book Association, a number of notable publishers and the excellent blog from Booklist,
Book Group Buzz. The great event was in October, alas; perhaps a little more publicity might be possible? Most of the books listed at the site are by women authors, and it's a diverse, enticing gathering, though it seems duplicative of other resources. The site also lists additional places to go, like
Book Movement, an item I will now bookmark and refer others to see.Oh, and the Man Booker Prize has gone to . Aravind Adiga for The White Tiger, one of only four first novels to receive this award. A
review in the Times of London says it is "quick, entertaining and full of vividly drawn types: the scheming servant, the corrupt businessman, the spoilt wife. Its lack of subtlety can be wearying, as can its cynicism. But it is a useful counter to optimistic tales of India's roaring economy." Coming to a library near you.Two articles of interest:"Reviving Literary Discussion: Book Club to Go Kits," by Virginia Hermes, Mary Anne Hile, and Johnetta L. Frisbie. Reference and User Services Quarterly, 48(1), Fall 2008."Urban Fiction Goes from Streets to Public Libraries," by Anne Barnard. New York Times, October 28, 2008. ("Barbara Orlandi . reads about the dangerous life she remembers . 'It actually helps you to understand what's going on around you,' she said, 'instead of walking around blind.'") See "Fiction as Life Preparation," above.
Books and Covers in Vanity FairIn observance of its 25th anniversary, the magazine Vanity Fair has listed the
25 best non-fiction books, and the
25 best book covers, among other "25 Best" lists on its Web site. There is much to disagree with! Visitors to the Web site can vote for their favorites.
Readers Respond
Catherine Nashak, of the Deer Park Public Library in Deer Park, NY, writes about my request for experiences of film/fiction combinations:
"Last spring, I began a daytime "Book & Movie" group. We have a large senior population, and many do not drive at night. Finding the right book has been challenging though. I had a fair turnout for the classic mystery, The Maltese Falcon, while showing the Humphrey Bogart version. The Manchurian Candidate was not successful. Wilkie Collins' The Moonstone was better; we had a brief discussion along with the Masterpiece Theatre version. We're giving it one more try with a discussion of Wuthering Heights, again followed by a Masterpiece Theatre production in November. This program seems to attract mainly women; getting more men to attend is a challenge. Depending on the turnout for Wuthering Heights, choosing classic mysteries may be the key." Catherine also notes that she has been leading a discussion group for nine years, fiction and nonfiction, sometime using documentary films to develop good discussions. Thank you, Catherine.
Write!
What would you add or subtract on my course reading list? What fiction would you recommend to President-Elect Barack Obama? What questions do you use to defrost a reading group? Would they fit on a bookmark?And, of course, I invite you all to
interview yourselves, one at a time, anonymously if you wish, for RA NewsThe editor is always grateful to readers who share responses or lessons. Please write to us at
mailto:RAEditor@ebscohost.com?subject=RA%20News%20Feedback%20November%2008Unsubscribe Forward to a friend Update settings View HTML newsletterSigning up for NoveList RA News is quick and easy!Simply go to
www.ebscohost.com/novelist and click on the Newsletters section.You'll also be able to sign up and view current editions of any of the newsletters offered by NoveList. Your comments and questions are important to us - please contact
mailto:RAEditor@ebscohost.com?subject=RA%20News%20Feedback with any concerns or suggestions.© 2008 EBSCO Publishing, Powered by The Title Source TM